| |
t
THE LIVING TRADITION MAGAZINE, February, 2004:
THE Peaceful
Ground is a faultless celebration of that rich seam of glorious Gaelic
song - some in extremely contemporary settings, which may surprise some
listeners. Maggie MacInnes' vocal beauty and purity so echoes that of
her mother, Flora MacNeil MBE - who has shared her vast and precious knowledge
of Gaeldom's most beautiful songs with her daughter. This album is the
embodiment of the living tradition; rousing Hebridean waulking songs sit
alongside moving Gaelic laments and timeless love songs. It all makes
for a memorable listening experience, and MacInnes' voice resonates at
one moment with an extraordinary emotional fragility, and at the next
with passion and great strength.
MacInnes'
clarsach playing flashes with prism-like precision throughout this finely-arranged
recording, and she's accompanied by some first rate musicians, including
Wendy Weatherby (cello), Graeme Hughes (guitars/percussion), Brian MacAlpine
(keyboards), Finlay MacDonald (pipes/whistles), and Marie Fielding (fiddle).
Flora MacNeil, and Maggie's sister Cairistiona provide backing vocals
on three songs. Their sensitively judged contributions are fundamental
to the album's sound.
You could divide the songs fairly equally between the rousing work songs
and the sublime love songs/laments. Of the more upbeat songs, perhaps
the most radical is 'Dh 'fhalbh mo run bho chionn seachdain', where MacInnes
dips into the family archive to include a treasured recording of her late
great aunt Mary Gillies of Barra. Trip hop rhythms, pipes and crunching
guitars accompany three generations of this exceptional family. This is
a superb song, and there are more like it! MacInnes also unearths a very
beautiful 'lost' Burns song, The Ewe Bughts - such hauntingly lyrical
whistle accompaniment. The album's lyrical opening song describes the
sensual delights of the Isle of Mull on a spring morning.
There are shades of Moya Brennan in MacInnes' own composition, the lovely
Peaceful Ground. Cairistiona is a lament of unrivalled beauty. Fhir An
Leadain Thlath is sung a cappella, and I cannot help but compare MacInnes'
version with her mother's on Orain Floraidh - the vocal similarities are
disconcerting. Here, MacInnes publicly thanks her mother for sharing her
songs with her - she's on record as saying that "they are so beautiful
and a real joy to sing."
Our joy in listening to them is immeasurable! Debbie Koritsas
SCOTSMAN,
6th February, 2004:
SINGER and clarsach player Maggie MacInnes's lovely, deftly inflected
Gaelic singing and gentle but evocative musical settings create a peaceful
musical ground of their own, with the occasional feistier offering adding
variety without disrupting the mood. She comes from a famous Barra family
in Gaelic song circles, and both her mother, the great Flora MacNeil,
and her sister, Cairistiona MacInnes, are heard singing with her here,
as is her late great aunt Mary Gillies, in an old recording. The self-composed
title track in English and a rarity by Burns in Scots are the only non-Gaelic
songs. Kenny Mathieson
PETE FYFE(www.folking.com)March,
2004;
I first came across the gently lilting voice of Maggie
MacInnes back in the early 80's on the album Cairistiona with George Jackson
and I'm pleased to say that she reprises that particular song here (surprisingly)
with the addition of understated electric guitar. The 80's were also about
the time that I became aware of the Gaelic language in song. I still can't
quite get to grips with it but if you take it as a texture mixed in with
the music it is more than palatable, as Clannad and Capercaillie have
proved on the mainstream market. OK, so lyrics aside, the album is a controlled
folk-rock exercise courtesy of producer Graeme Hughes which at times crosses
over into Martyn Bennett territory where the skirl of highland pipes add
passion to an already evocative "Dh'fhalbh mo run bho chionn seachdain".
Interestingly the vocals of Maggie joined by her mother the great Flora
MacNeil on the same track conjure up images of Native Americans at a gathering.
Whereas her previous recording was perhaps a little more subdued in it's
arrangements, Maggie has surrounded herself with some of Scotland's finest
musicians including Sean O'Rourke (saxophone), Wendy Weatherby (cello)
and Brian MacAlpine on keyboards and the overall performances on this
album are far more dramatic. Take for instance the waulking song "Haidh
O" where the use of stick driven rhythm and crashing electric guitars
create a powerful, edgy performance. Although not rocking in the true
sense of the word this is an album that is refreshing without being in
your face and a joy to listen to.
SONGLINES
MAGAZINE May, 2004;
Maggie
MacInnes is the daughter of revered singer Flora MacNeil (who provides
some backing vocals on this album) and, along with Karen Matheson and
Alyth McCormack, she's one of the finest contemporary Gaelic voices around.
In this third solo album she stretches the boundaries with a range of
modern interpretations of traditional Gaelic songs, plus one self-composed
English-language number and one Scots song by Burns.
MacInnes
is at her best when the arrangements are at their simplest. 'S toil leam
an Cìobair', for the most part featuring only her singing and clarsach
(harp), achieves a wonderful purity and clarity. The addition of the saxophone
(Sean O'Rourke) towards the end is unexpected but successful, adding a
real contemporary twist. 'Thig an Smeòrach as t-Earrach' is Gaelic singing
at its best, accompanied by Brian MacAlpine's lyrical piano and Wendy
Weatherby's cello; the emotional power will stop you in your tracks. And
MacInnes's take on Burns's 'The Ewe Bughts' includes original music by
her based on a traditional air - it's a great tune.
One problem is the use of electric guitar and keyboards which, despite
the good arrangements, detract more than they add. But the acoustic instruments,
including fiddle, pipes, whistles and guitar, are much more successful,
and the album's defining sounds - MacInnes's singing and clarsach playing
- are consistently excellent. - - - - -Andy Jurgis
|
|
 |